All-Star Ballot Update – Week 2

With two weeks of All-Star voting in the books, we are quickly getting a good idea of which players will be attending the 2012 All-Star Game in Ottawa and which players will be left at home. 

The NHL released their second voting update today, giving us plenty of material to analyze. 

Top-15 Forwards

* Write-in candidate
1.           Phil Kessel 258,446
2. Daniel Alfredsson 233,868
3. Jason Spezza 209,455
4. Sidney Crosby 206,863
5. Milan Michalek 190,670
6. Joffrey Lupul 166,787
7. Claude Giroux 151,001
8. Jonathan Toews 137,387
9. Jaromir Jagr 126,250
10. Patrick Kane 120,439
11. Evgeni Malkin 110,576
12. Pavel Datsyuk 98,415
13. Marian Hossa 95,781
14. James Neal 95,454
15. Alex Ovechkin 88,222

Phil Kessel not only leads all forwards in total votes, but also leads the entire league in total votes received with 258,446. Kessel is certainly deserving given his 31 points which lead the NHL heading into Tuesday’s action. 

Scan the rest of the list and you’ll see that to date, the Eastern Conference has done a much better job of mobilizing their vote than the Western Conference has, save Chicago. Also worth noticing is that despite having a pretty disappointing season so far, Alex Ovechkin’s name recognition has been enough to place him 15th at the forward position. 

While he’s not included in the top-15, coming in at 22nd with 68,107 votes is Tyler Seguin, a write-in candidate. It’d be nice to see Seguin end up making the All-Star squad as it was a pretty glaring oversight to leave him off the actual ballot.

Top-15 Defenseman


* Write-in candidate

1.         Erik Karlsson 256,839
2. Dion Phaneuf 213,617
3. Kris Letang 195,528
4. Zdeno Chara 184,457
5. Nicklas Lidstrom 169,218
6. Sergei Gonchar 153,874
7. Duncan Keith 135,049
8. John-Michael Liles 133,379
9. Shea Weber 114,063
10. Brent Seabrook 108,723
11. Chris Pronger 100,076
12. P.K. Subban 93,427
13. Kimmo Timonen 91,273
14. Alexander Edler 80,538
15. Dan Boyle 61,823

Young Erik Karlsson continues to lead the way from the blueline, with 20 assists through 23 games. Familiar names such as Letang, Chara and Lidstrom round out the top-5. Chris Pronger currently is 11th with just over 100,000 votes, but that number will likely trail off as he will miss significant time with knee surgery. 

Top-15 Goaltenders

* Write-in candidate
1.          Tim Thomas 175,315
2. Marc-Andre Fleury 169,721
3. James Reimer 161,405
4. Pekka Rinne 101,570
5. Carey Price 93,637
6. Henrik Lundqvist 92,808
7. Ilya Bryzgalov 84,498
8. Nikolai Khabibulin 79,126
9. Roberto Luongo 67,719
10. Jonathan Quick 56,654
11. Kari Lehtonen 55,956
12. Corey Crawford 53,604
13. Ryan Miller 45,768
14. Jimmy Howard 44,610
15. Martin Brodeur 39,899

Tim Thomas leads all goaltenders with just over 175,000 votes, followed by Marc-Andre Fleury and … James Reimer? Despite being sidelined with concussion-like symptoms, Reimer finds himself 3rd in total voting with just six games played this year. As we’ve seen time and time again, fans will vote for the guys they know/like and not base their votes on actual performances – or even on whether the guy is playing or not.

As noted, two goaltenders, Corey Crawford and Jimmy Howard, are receiving a ton of votes despite not being listed on the ballot. A pretty big blunder by the NHL to leave Howard and Crawford off the ballot, it’s great to see fans giving credit where credit is due.

One name that is missing from this list is Brian Elliott. His name is nowhere to be found in this recent update from the NHL which is a shame given his start to the year that is leading the NHL in numerous categories (GAA and save percentage, as of the date of this article). Unfortunately, fantastic numbers aside, it’s no shocker that Elliott is nowhere to be found as not only was he not on the ballot but his success has truly come out of thin air. 

We’ll continue to keep an eye on all the All-Star ballot results as we creep closer to the actual game. Stay tuned.

About David Rogers

Editor for The Comeback and Contributing Editor for Awful Announcing. Lover of hockey, soccer and all things pop culture.